Greetings...
The truth for a person might be a lies to another person. Take religion for example. If anybody put a knife on my neck and asked me to convert my religion, I might defend my belief until the end of my life. I believe most of you will do the same regardless what your religion is. I do not believe the teachings that my Buddhist friends, my Hindus friends, my Christians friends, even my Scientologist friends [if I have Scientologist friend in the future] believe, but I definitely respect them and respect their beliefs. In facts, I believe it is a sin to belittle other Gods and other religions. That is why when I first interested in knowing what is Scientology Church [in which John Travolta, Tom Cruise, etc. are the firm believers and the belief has connection with a story of aliens inhabitant 75 millions years ago], my first impression is 'Gosh, this is ridiculous!'. But then I came to my senses, I should respect what they believe accordingly.
Allow me to go much deeper on this issue...
In early 1990's, I took my A-Level at PPP/ITM Shah Alam, Selangor. There was a time, during our religion studies, a religious teacher or Ustaz asked a very provocative question [this Ustaz was known later as anti-hadith Ustaz according to rumor, and transferred after his first class with us].
WARNING: Please do not continue reading this article if you think you are not up to it.
The Question from the Ustaz was something like this...
'Assuming that you were born in Swizerland, born in a Christian family, exposed to Christian life, went to church every Sunday and did lots of charity works, and then you die... do you think you still go to heaven?' A spontaneous response from one of my classmate, 'Of course not, because I died as a Christian, not as a Muslim'. The Ustaz asked again, 'Who made you born in Swizerland? Who made you a Christian? Who made you live in Christian environment? Who made you died as a Christian? Who put you into hell and not heaven? Is it all of them done by God? So, do you think God is fair?!' [His actual word were 'Jadi, adilkah Tuhan?' and I still remember those words until now.]
I believe I talk on behalf of all of my classmate during that time that our heartbeats literally STOPPED. What the heck man? An Ustaz came out with such question and during that time all of us were very young and immatured to talk about such big issue. That is a very irresponsible act.
To be honest with all of you, the Question really lingered in my mind for years until I found another Ustaz [not a Malaysian] while I studied oversea. I did ask this Ustaz almost similar Question. The Arabian Ustaz answered me in front of everybody, cautiously, and before he gave me the answer, he kept telling all the congregates in the mosque that his answer was taken from a group of Islamic Scholar's Fatwa or Decree in early 1900.
The Answer is, 'God will judge you according to your religion if the truth of Islam is not reach you. The definition of 'the truth of Islam is not reaching you' is up to God Himself. If a community that live in an isolated island and never heard to any of the Islam Gospel, never know the teaching of Islam, never heard of the name of Muhammad as the last Prophet in this world; we are certain that they will be judged in according to their island religion. If they behave well, never harm anybody, obey the islander rules, etc. they will not be put into hell. However, if they already knew about Islam, knew about the teaching of Islam, heard about Muhammad and started to believe in them BUT purposely reject Islam to be their religion just because they do not want to forego their interest in this world, then they will go to hell. This is similar to Abu Lahab and the rest of the Musyrikin 14 centuries ago.
I asked again, 'what about someone who heard about Islam but the words about Islam do not trigger them to know more, to learn more, and they still believe in their own religion not because of the interest of the world, but because they believe they could become a better person as a Christians, or Buddhists, or Hidus, etc. What about them? Could they be classified similar to the Musyrikins or the island people that never heard about the name of Islam at all?'
The Ustaz answered, 'That is something you and me could tell. That is something that only God knows, the Creator knows, not to be known by the creations like you and me.' The Ustaz added, 'We already knew that God is fair and the fairness of God is beyond our understanding as human being. So do you think God will misjudge people whether to put them into heaven or hell; whether to classify them as the Musyrikin or the islander; if according to you, these people might lies in the between? So, your question just now could not be answered and we must believe God is fair in his judgment in the case of the Swizerland guy.'
This is a serious matter. If any of you [who read this article] is a respected Ustaz or Mufti, please do not hesitate to make any correction on the opinion given by the Arabian Ustaz above. But make sure your response is not merely based on emotion and baseless without any supporting argument from Al-Qur'an or Hadith or 'Ijmak Ulamak'.
So what is my conclusion that I would like to share here? Never say that a non-Muslim will definitely go to hell as much as never say that a Muslim will definitely go to heaven [he might be a Muslim in name but non-Muslim in term of behavior]. God is the judge, let God make the judgment. We are human being and as a human being, it is safe not to be judgmental by determining who [in our opinion] goes to heaven or hell. Like what been said by Haji Labu [in P. Ramlee's Labu Labi movie], 'I don't know whether I go to heaven or I go to hell?' But as a Muslim, we strive to be a better person [or putting Robbie William's song into perspective, a 'Better Man'] and hope that God will accept us in the day of Judgment.
Thank you for your valuable time.
Dr. Tahoma
The truth for a person might be a lies to another person. Take religion for example. If anybody put a knife on my neck and asked me to convert my religion, I might defend my belief until the end of my life. I believe most of you will do the same regardless what your religion is. I do not believe the teachings that my Buddhist friends, my Hindus friends, my Christians friends, even my Scientologist friends [if I have Scientologist friend in the future] believe, but I definitely respect them and respect their beliefs. In facts, I believe it is a sin to belittle other Gods and other religions. That is why when I first interested in knowing what is Scientology Church [in which John Travolta, Tom Cruise, etc. are the firm believers and the belief has connection with a story of aliens inhabitant 75 millions years ago], my first impression is 'Gosh, this is ridiculous!'. But then I came to my senses, I should respect what they believe accordingly.
Allow me to go much deeper on this issue...
In early 1990's, I took my A-Level at PPP/ITM Shah Alam, Selangor. There was a time, during our religion studies, a religious teacher or Ustaz asked a very provocative question [this Ustaz was known later as anti-hadith Ustaz according to rumor, and transferred after his first class with us].
WARNING: Please do not continue reading this article if you think you are not up to it.
The Question from the Ustaz was something like this...
'Assuming that you were born in Swizerland, born in a Christian family, exposed to Christian life, went to church every Sunday and did lots of charity works, and then you die... do you think you still go to heaven?' A spontaneous response from one of my classmate, 'Of course not, because I died as a Christian, not as a Muslim'. The Ustaz asked again, 'Who made you born in Swizerland? Who made you a Christian? Who made you live in Christian environment? Who made you died as a Christian? Who put you into hell and not heaven? Is it all of them done by God? So, do you think God is fair?!' [His actual word were 'Jadi, adilkah Tuhan?' and I still remember those words until now.]
I believe I talk on behalf of all of my classmate during that time that our heartbeats literally STOPPED. What the heck man? An Ustaz came out with such question and during that time all of us were very young and immatured to talk about such big issue. That is a very irresponsible act.
To be honest with all of you, the Question really lingered in my mind for years until I found another Ustaz [not a Malaysian] while I studied oversea. I did ask this Ustaz almost similar Question. The Arabian Ustaz answered me in front of everybody, cautiously, and before he gave me the answer, he kept telling all the congregates in the mosque that his answer was taken from a group of Islamic Scholar's Fatwa or Decree in early 1900.
The Answer is, 'God will judge you according to your religion if the truth of Islam is not reach you. The definition of 'the truth of Islam is not reaching you' is up to God Himself. If a community that live in an isolated island and never heard to any of the Islam Gospel, never know the teaching of Islam, never heard of the name of Muhammad as the last Prophet in this world; we are certain that they will be judged in according to their island religion. If they behave well, never harm anybody, obey the islander rules, etc. they will not be put into hell. However, if they already knew about Islam, knew about the teaching of Islam, heard about Muhammad and started to believe in them BUT purposely reject Islam to be their religion just because they do not want to forego their interest in this world, then they will go to hell. This is similar to Abu Lahab and the rest of the Musyrikin 14 centuries ago.
I asked again, 'what about someone who heard about Islam but the words about Islam do not trigger them to know more, to learn more, and they still believe in their own religion not because of the interest of the world, but because they believe they could become a better person as a Christians, or Buddhists, or Hidus, etc. What about them? Could they be classified similar to the Musyrikins or the island people that never heard about the name of Islam at all?'
The Ustaz answered, 'That is something you and me could tell. That is something that only God knows, the Creator knows, not to be known by the creations like you and me.' The Ustaz added, 'We already knew that God is fair and the fairness of God is beyond our understanding as human being. So do you think God will misjudge people whether to put them into heaven or hell; whether to classify them as the Musyrikin or the islander; if according to you, these people might lies in the between? So, your question just now could not be answered and we must believe God is fair in his judgment in the case of the Swizerland guy.'
This is a serious matter. If any of you [who read this article] is a respected Ustaz or Mufti, please do not hesitate to make any correction on the opinion given by the Arabian Ustaz above. But make sure your response is not merely based on emotion and baseless without any supporting argument from Al-Qur'an or Hadith or 'Ijmak Ulamak'.
So what is my conclusion that I would like to share here? Never say that a non-Muslim will definitely go to hell as much as never say that a Muslim will definitely go to heaven [he might be a Muslim in name but non-Muslim in term of behavior]. God is the judge, let God make the judgment. We are human being and as a human being, it is safe not to be judgmental by determining who [in our opinion] goes to heaven or hell. Like what been said by Haji Labu [in P. Ramlee's Labu Labi movie], 'I don't know whether I go to heaven or I go to hell?' But as a Muslim, we strive to be a better person [or putting Robbie William's song into perspective, a 'Better Man'] and hope that God will accept us in the day of Judgment.
Thank you for your valuable time.
Dr. Tahoma